The Gold Standard Directory

The best insurance agents in Baraboo, WI

S

#1GOLD STANDARD PICK

Schwarz Insurance Agency

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

4.9 stars93 reviews

T

#2

TRICOR Insurance

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

4.8 stars93 reviews

J

#3

Johnsen Insurance

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

4.8 stars47 reviews

W

#4

Wisconsin River Title Consultants LLC

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

4.8 stars42 reviews

O

#5

Oliver Adjustment Company, Inc

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

2.6 stars25 reviews

J

#6

John Donahue Insurance

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

5.0 stars12 reviews

B

#7

Bartels Insurance Services, LLC

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

5.0 stars7 reviews

A

#8

Andrews Insurance - The Covenant Agency

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

5.0 stars3 reviews

B

#9

Burkhalter Travel Agency Inc

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

4.2 stars13 reviews

B

#10

Baraboo Mutual Insurance Company

Insurance agents, Baraboo, WI

3.0 stars2 reviews

How the order is set: in each area and niche, the highest Google rating among businesses with at least 25 Google reviews comes first, a tie goes to more reviews, and businesses with fewer reviews follow. The first card is the Gold Standard Pick. Ratings, reviews and contact details are from our own scan of the area. Nobody can pay for a place. Updated November 15, 2026.

The Gold Standard Directory by The Algo Vision.